This sweater looks every bit as good in person as it does in the pics. The site suggest an XL for my desired fit, so thats what I ordered and it fits exactly as I wanted it to. I'm 5'9" and about 190 lbs., slim build with some extra around the middle, and this sweater looks good on me! Fits well in the arms and shoulders with just a little extra space for my belly. The quality seems to be good. It's a lightweight sweater, but all the stitching seems to be first rate. This was my first Oxknit purchase and I will be making more based upon the quality of this garment!